Friday, January 25, 2008

Primary Choices: John McCain

NY Times Editorial
Primary Choices: John McCain
Published: January 25, 2008
The senator from Arizona is the best choice for the Republican Party’s presidential nomination.


Clearly, the NY Times had a hard time saying anything positive about any Republican candidate. That said, the information about Senator McCain gives support to my previous feelings about him. I know that people in AZ have respect for him. I respect his status as a POW and war veteran and believe that he would make (unlike Senator Clinton) a strong commander-in-chief. Perhaps his greatest strength (shared previously with Bob Dole) is that he can commit himself to a principle and stick to it in spite of personal loss. I'm referring to his stance on torture and how he views it as abhorrent and un-American. I must agree. There has to be a better way to deal with the issue. I also liked how the NY Times talked about his ability to work with Democrats. I have to say, for all of the abusive language and hard feelings that fly back and forth between the two parties, there are good people on both sides and we do have a lot of things in common. I'm not convinced that either Republicans or Democrats have a monopoly on the solutions to the problems America faces.

As for the other Republican hopefuls, let me start with Rudy Giuliani. He is running his campaign on positive press from 9/11 and clearly not everyone in New York respects or likes him. You'd be hard pressed to find a more stinging indictment of him than the one presented in this article. So far I have yet to see anything from him other than that he wants to be president. If that's all he's got, no thanks.

As for Mike Huckabee, he is a populist with a friendly exterior and no substance to his policy proposals. His use of religion against Mitt Romney angers me.

Now, for Mitt Romney, I'm still trying to figure out what to think. Part of me wants to see a Mormon do well in spite of his religion. I suppose that's part of the appeal to me for Hillary and Barack in their historic campaigns as well. I respect Romney's religious beliefs as I too am a Mormon. When you compare his family life to that of the other candidates, the other candidates have nothing on him. Nevertheless, I still know relatively little about him. My understanding is that he rescued the Winter Olympics that were held in Salt Lake City. I thought it remarkable that a Republican was elected as governor of Massachusetts. I do not know much about what he did in either of those two roles and want to learn more. That said, my impression so far is that he is an able administrator and would do well as president. One of my major concerns about Mitt is that he would serve (as Bush has) the wealthy set of Republicans. I do not see how we can keep giving tax breaks to the wealthiest people in America.

9 comments:

Darin said...

Mitt Romney is a sleaze ball, he'll sell his soul for a vote. He stands for nothing but what is adventageous for him at the time--worse than anyone in this race. Oh, and following his leadership, the republican candidate (his Leitenant Governor) lost soundly, ending the Bay state's trend of electing Repbulican governors that had lasted for more that 15 years. And I agree with your thoughts on his giving cuts to the ultra-wealthy, we can see how well that's working.
The NY Times isn't that (italicized) liberal.
Go McCain!! For now at least!

James Clemans said...

Are you kidding me. The Facts say otherwise.
To say nothing of your personal attack lets get the facts straight. His Lt. Gov. didn't lose because of Mitt, she lost herself.
If you read the New York Times everyone knows its liberal and Democratic. As is most of the media. FACT. They along with you bash Mitt. Check out the reporters voting records, the vast majority are democrats. Check out broadcasters, vast majority democrats. Why do you think they bash Mitt. They're afraid of him.
He took over a state 3 billion in debt, cut taxes and ended with a surplus. Plus, in a democratic state worked with democrats to pass legislation. And succeeded.
He's a winner, an economist, a businessman. I watched and listened to him take a scandal ridden Olympics, turn it around, and over 100 million in surplus back into Utah. And he took no pay.
Research the candidates, listen to the debates, see what programs they promote, see their voting records. Mitt is for real, has a real plan, and has a proven record of success. Those are the facts.
Republican conservatives are voting for Mitt, Democrats and Liberals more for McCann. FACT
I am sick of the personal attacks and religious bigotry of those attacking Mitt. He's Christian, move on.
Study the candidates.

Unknown said...

I think you need to study the candidates. I am well aware of Mitt Romney's economic record. He cut taxes and increased so many fees in Mass. that he put an increased burden on lower income people. He did save the Olympics, but govt. doesn't run like the Olympic Comm. and never will. It isn't designed to.

Mitt Romney is a business man who only cares about the profit margin and benefitting other millionaires like himself. I suppose I should respect his ability to go from being a rich man's son to a rich man, but somehow the climb doesn't seem so spectacular. I respected his father, speaking the truth about Vietnam at a time when it was very unpopular to do so, but Mitt has shown little of his father's integrity. He has changed positions on so many issues so many times, I wonder if he even cares about those issues. I personally would respect him more if he simply came out and said "I changed sides on abortion because it isn't going to make a difference. I am here as the money man." But he would never be that forthright because the GOP would never nominate him then. But that isn't surprising considering that he would have lost reelection too.

And no one on this blog has insinuated that Mitt Romney is not a christian. In fact, I am willing to bet that everyone who has commented here so far is a mormon themselves and are well aware of the church being The Church of Jesus Christ.

And as for the myth of the liberal press, you guys need to come up with a new attack line. It is verifiably untrue that the media is liberal. Conservatives have done such a good job of filling the airwaves with hatemongering filth, it has choked out the truth.

James Clemans said...

R. Morrissey,
Such anger, perhaps anger management is needed. First of all, My response was directed to Darin's comments on Mitt Romney and his personal attacks. Second, I don't know where you get the idea that the media isn't liberal. Again, check out the reporters, (newspaper & broadcast) their background, their politics, their writing, their newspapers articles and you will learn their politics and their agendas. My background both as a researcher for years and in my younger years as a reporter in college and afterwards makes me take exception with your interpretation of the media. By your comments it is apparent that you aren't interested in a discussion of the facts but more interested in doing what you accuse the conservatives and republicans of doing. I'm not a republican, but your comments make them look very appealing.

Unknown said...

The jury is still out for myself as to who I'll vote for, but referencing your comment on the rich receiving another tax break, the rich American's I know frankly work smarter and more hours than the not so rich I know, and I don't think they should be penalized for it. Currently U.S. income tax is tiered, meaning when you reach a new tax bracket the dollars you earn in that bracket are taxed higher. Where's the incentive for Americans to earn more money just to suffer more taxes? That is an economic efficiency, so it is arguable that some people drag their heels at work ethic because although they could work more, and earn more, it will just be taxed even more, so they don’t. The Rich should receive tax breaks on their dollars earned in those higher tiers so they are being taxed the same as those complacent or ignorant folks who earn poverty wages. The real issue is not “should we lower taxes for the rich;” we should. The real issue is not “should the poor receive more aid;” they should. The real issue is “what aid should the poor, and middle class receive;” and the answer is “the opportunity for financial education.” If everyone is given equal opportunity for financial education, what they do with it or don’t do with it is in their court. Most middle class individuals stay in the middle class because they spend their money on liabilities (expenses) that deplete their income. The Rich have learned to purchase assets with their income (investing in things that make them more money); therefore, most people who are rich did not become rich off of their income, but rather what they do with it. Schools don’t teach financial education like they should.

Unknown said...

In reference to a follow up email, I received from Kasey:

I agree that many of the rich got there because of luck, or unethical practices, and that many of them are not the most intelligent, or gifted.

You mentioned, however, that many of those who are rich likely started off in a higher class and therefore they had connections or privileges not available to those of lower classes, which you refer to as an uneven playing field. I respectfully disagree.

There are enough people in this world with more money than they need who spend their days trying to spend it, whether by investing it, or blowing it on whatever. If people would stop looking to some employer as a means to make a living but rather look at the markets in which people spend their money, they could set themselves up to have those markets paying them rather than some employer. I do not blame employers for squeezing everything they can from their employees; it is necessary for companies to do so they can stay in business and stay in the market; and their employees need to learn to stop disrespecting themselves. I believe anyone with a good idea and the education to make a profit from that good idea has access to the money necessary to implement it, and thereby we cannot blame others for our poverty. People looking to spend their money on an investment don't necessarily look at the bank account of the person proposing it, but rather they look at the following things:

-The idea that this person has; is there a market for it?

-can this person deliver?

-Will the market pay enough to recoup the cost, and put enough money back in the pockets of those involved, to be worth investing anything in it?

If the educational system were to focus on teaching people to watch for these market opportunities, and teach people how to position their ideas strategically in those markets, so as to fully exploit the resources to their fullest potential, it would allow all who are willing to be competitive in this game of wealth. Beyond that, the choice is up to the individual. Many do not want to learn these things, and because of their lack of drive, they will work for someone else as a fully exploited resource until the day their frustration with being nothing more than a spinning tire causes them to seek more education.

There is a lot of available government assistance and other assistance to those pursuing education. The internet is available to nearly all within America, particularly through public libraries, where books themselves provide a free education.

In the paraphrased words written and spoken by Matt Damon in "Good Will Hunting," I quote, "You paid a hundred and fifty grand for an education you could of got for a dollar fifty in late charges at your local library," and I add, "whose the idiot now."

I feel bad for no American based on their class distinction of wealth so far as the long run is concerned.

As to your favor towards progressive tax, I again respectfully disagree. Just because those with more wealth can afford accountants to save them more money in taxes, does not mean that progressive tax is the right solution to any problem. Tithing, for one, is evidence in my mind that if we aren't ready to give our all under the law of consecration, then He is in favor of flat tax. I don't know what this nation needs more money for anyway, but if it does, let's look at the theory of constraints, which in short says that things cost so much; therefore, you can spend the rest of your days trying to cut costs another 5 cents, or you could accept the fact that costs are pretty well cut, and focus your energies on contributing to gains. This is again where educating the middle and lower class to purchase assets rather than liabilities comes in. If American citizens made more (and not just the rich ones), then the whole nation gets more in taxes. Progressive tax is like welfare, in that while it may benefit someone sometime, it only does so by impinging on someone else; it's time to teach people to walk on their own two feet and contribute more; not take away incentive to make more because of taking away welfare, or adding a higher tax.

Besides, you don't need a fancy accountant to learn the common knowledge that c corporations pay taxes after expenses, not on revenues, while individuals pay taxes on revenues, not after expenses; therefore, anyone who wants to avoid taxes can just start up an entity separate from themselves (like a private c corporation that is not required to publically disclose their financial statements), spend whatever they want as their expenses (like their house and car and vacations, etc) and then pay taxes on what is left (nothing). Because c corporations are legal entities separate from any individual, the expenses are left up to the owners of the corporations as to whether they are in the best interest of the business or not. The only trick is that the c corporation needs to do business, have transactions, etc, which means people need to contribute something to the world to do this.

If my understanding is lacking in reference to any of these comments, I welcome correction, as I don't profess to know much of anything except that I'm a flip flopper; I change my mind in light of further knowledge all the time

James Clemans said...

cclemans:
I enjoyed your thoughtful and intelligent posts. I agree with most of your comments in both of your posts to date. As to your comment on taxes I favor the straight sales tax. Do away with the tax levels, no tax on groceries/food, that way you pay everytime you buy. No loopholes, no IRS pressure, less litigation, less IRS and bureacracy. The difficulty is getting people to mobilize to get it done as with all things. I've written to my congressmen and senators but until more do and they feel pressure to do something nothing will change.

Klemm said...

For everyone's reference, this is the email I sent Chad in response to his comment that begins with "The jury is still out..." dated 25 January 2008 8:49 pm.

Thank you for your thoughts Chad. I agree with many of the things you said. Especially what you said about financial education and the middle class and how people acquire assets or liabilities. However, I have seen things in my current and previous jobs that lead me to believe that the rich are not necessarily so because they have managed their money better. In part, they may have actually taken advantage of others to make their profits. People will work to feed their families. Their opportunities may be limited and the job market may not be that great and so they will take less than what they feel they need or deserve, because it’s at least something and will keep them alive. The disproportionate salaries in America disgust me. Especially when I know there are people sitting and the top grinding every ounce of “productivity” out of their workers. Their economic incentives push them to pay as little as possible for as much as possible. What leverage do those at the other end have when their choice to not accept what they are offered means that the boss just moves on to the next guy leaving them without a job and as a result no means of supporting their families? Just because they can squeeze all of the surplus out of their workers because of their superior leverage, that does not make it right. Furthermore, I’m not convinced that the people at the top of the corporate ladder are the most intelligent or are all that gifted. I concede that some of them are. However, just because they are being paid all of that money does not mean they actually earn it, deserve it, or are worth it. I think luck plays a larger part in that than most of them would like to admit. Odds are they started off in a higher class and were able to move into their current position with class-related connections and/or privileges that lower class individuals are either unaware of or ineligible for. I do not believe that the playing field in America is level.

I am for progressive taxes that require larger percentages from households with higher incomes. That said, we do not want to be like Europe and remove economic incentives to innovate and produce. I would be interested to know how much Americans in various tiers actually pay. The richer they get, the more they can afford to pay their accountant to save them money. My impression is that the American tax code is like a sieve when it comes to loopholes. I may very well be wrong, but the fact that accounting is such a booming industry (everywhere you look, people want to hire accountants) leads me to believe that the wealthy are still managing to manipulate the system.

So, there is my response. I enjoyed your email and had fun writing back. It’s the first time I’ve verbalized some of these views that have kind of developed over time. I hope you’ll continue to share what you know with me. You have had experiences and coursework that I have not and I like getting new perspectives.

James Clemans said...

To R Morrissey,
I regret the comment on anger management which after reflection was wrong on my part to suggest and wish to apologize.
James Clemans