Why is it that people cannot handle it when others bash their country? (I realize the pronouns could be clearer, but hopefully you get my drift) I was just reading an argument between an elderly American man and a young Russian girl. They are going back and forth about the conflict in South Ossetia. (If you are curious, the group is called "Ossetian conflict" on Facebook.com).
Observing their argument, it was apparent that both sides were stridently trying to assert the validity of their respective positions. They want to force the other person to believe what they believe and are saying. I look at the exchange and see how nothing gets done. People just get upset and yell at each other. So what then is the best way to get another to come around to your way of thinking? Loudly proclaiming your position in concert with disgust for views that differ from your own is not effective. Even if you "win" the argument, you still do not achieve your purpose. You may trounce your opponent rhetorically, but he (English really needs a gender neutral third person pronoun) still walks away holding on to his position stronger than ever. You cannot force someone to believe that you are right.
How would you set up a constructive exchange of starkly divergent views? Can it be done if the various parties are predisposed to spend their time thinking of rebuttals rather than listening and working to comprehend what another party is saying?
Where does all the passion and fervor for one's nation come from?
It comes from how people identify themselves. I am an American. As such, there are certain qualities I ascribe to America as a whole. At the same time, there are some of these qualities that I claim for myself; they make up part of my identity. When someone lashes out against America or its leaders, I may perceive that as an attack not on a distant, unrelated third party, but a personal attack on who I am and what I believe in. Perhaps there is nothing more sacred or fragile to a person, than their own estimate of self-worth. We wear ourselves out trying bolster and defend this fragile sculpture.
I once had a fight, an intense verbal argument, with a close friend. We were roommates and worked together 24/7 for several months. I do not recall having many arguments with him before or after, but I do remember this one. I do not remember how we got on the topic, but my friend made a comment which I took to mean that he thought his country was better than mine. This, of course, was absurd to me. I assured him that I am from the greatest country on the planet. The closest thing we had to a rival had fallen and disintegrated. If the world was a playground, we would be the king of the hill. Those are not my exact words, but the idea of American supremacy to any and all other countries was present. He proceeded to bash America. I then bashed his country. Looking back, we were not so much defending our countries as those parts of our identities that were wrapped up in our countries. We were fighting to protect our perceptions of our own self-worth.
How can a person move beyond the frenetic struggle to maintain their own self-worth?
The only sure core a person can have is knowing who they are. This knowledge transcends national, racial, economic and all other boundaries. People possessing this knowledge know that they are in fact children of God, known by and loved of Him with a love as real as any tender parent's care for their helpless infant. Only when you have this knowledge and learn to rely on it, to test it by your faith, can you be free of the daily rituals of building yourself up and fending off perceived threats. Only then can you be secure enough to move beyond the zero-sum-game mentality and treat those with whom you disagree, not as enemies to be conquered, but as siblings to be understood.
That, at least, is a step in the right direction.
Friday, August 22, 2008
Sunday, August 17, 2008
Papa Cito
A week ago, my dad, whom I frequently call Papa cito - I'm fairly certain that's incorrect Spanish, but oh well - came to visit me. It was the first time that a family member has made the trip out here to the DC area since I moved out here a year ago.
It was great to see him. I had had the idea that maybe he could come a couple of months ago. I had been thinking about making a trip out to Utah to visit before school started, but it just did not look practical from most any angle I looked at it. I simply did not have the time or means to make it happen. When I realized that, I decided to ask my dad if he would come out and see me. Judging from his reaction, it was like I had given him a Christmas present (not just the usual, but one he actually liked :) He made the arrangements for his flight and worked hard to get his work schedule under control so that he could take the time away.
I had a great time with him here. I got to take him over and show him around George Mason Law. We also took a trip to the National Archives and looked at the Consitution, Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights. After that, we went and got some grub and watched Get Smart (which both of us found to be much funnier than we had anticipated - I would recommend seeing it) On Saturday, I took him to the Maryland side of Great Falls. We took some pictures and watched the kayakers that were negotiating the Potomac right there. We also got to see a demonstration of the lock system on the Chesapeake/Ohio canal that runs parallel to the river. That was actually pretty cool. Saturday night we relaxed with some hefty servings of ice cream and watched the Olympics.
On Sunday, my dad gave me a blessing before church. That had been one of the main reasons I had asked him to come. I have received a blessing each year of college and did not want to embark on my law school journey without the added strength and comfort that comes from a priesthood blessing.
At church, my dad spent a couple of hours helping me get the clerks' office into a workable state. I could not have done it without him and was sorry he got dragged into it, but grateful for his help.
After church, we went over to Bronwyn & Emma's house for dinner. I had invited a bunch of friends and B & E were gracious enough to allow me to host the dinner at their place ( I don't really have a dining room at my place) Anyway, I was in charge of the main entree which was a dish called Saucy Chicken. The recipe is a favorite of mine that my mom makes. She got it from Aunt Renee. Anyway, things were going well with making the food until I noticed the cook time in the oven was supposed to be 2 hours! Steve heard that and went to Brad's for pancakes ( I would have joined him if I wasn't hosting :D As a result, we had plenty of time to sit and talk until dinner was ready. Overall it turned out good with the Saucy chicken, egg noodles, baked potatoes, salad, bread, and yummy dessert. I was stuffed to the rafters! After dinner we all hung out and talked. It was a lot of fun. It reminded me how lucky I am to have such good friends! Oh, I almost forgot; I looked hot in my chef's apron :P
On Monday, my dad and I visited the Masonic Memorial to George Washington and Christ's Church in Old Town Alexandria. We made a quick visit to Five Guys before I took him to the airport. It was a quick trip, but I was so glad he came.
It was great to see him. I had had the idea that maybe he could come a couple of months ago. I had been thinking about making a trip out to Utah to visit before school started, but it just did not look practical from most any angle I looked at it. I simply did not have the time or means to make it happen. When I realized that, I decided to ask my dad if he would come out and see me. Judging from his reaction, it was like I had given him a Christmas present (not just the usual, but one he actually liked :) He made the arrangements for his flight and worked hard to get his work schedule under control so that he could take the time away.
I had a great time with him here. I got to take him over and show him around George Mason Law. We also took a trip to the National Archives and looked at the Consitution, Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights. After that, we went and got some grub and watched Get Smart (which both of us found to be much funnier than we had anticipated - I would recommend seeing it) On Saturday, I took him to the Maryland side of Great Falls. We took some pictures and watched the kayakers that were negotiating the Potomac right there. We also got to see a demonstration of the lock system on the Chesapeake/Ohio canal that runs parallel to the river. That was actually pretty cool. Saturday night we relaxed with some hefty servings of ice cream and watched the Olympics.
On Sunday, my dad gave me a blessing before church. That had been one of the main reasons I had asked him to come. I have received a blessing each year of college and did not want to embark on my law school journey without the added strength and comfort that comes from a priesthood blessing.
At church, my dad spent a couple of hours helping me get the clerks' office into a workable state. I could not have done it without him and was sorry he got dragged into it, but grateful for his help.
After church, we went over to Bronwyn & Emma's house for dinner. I had invited a bunch of friends and B & E were gracious enough to allow me to host the dinner at their place ( I don't really have a dining room at my place) Anyway, I was in charge of the main entree which was a dish called Saucy Chicken. The recipe is a favorite of mine that my mom makes. She got it from Aunt Renee. Anyway, things were going well with making the food until I noticed the cook time in the oven was supposed to be 2 hours! Steve heard that and went to Brad's for pancakes ( I would have joined him if I wasn't hosting :D As a result, we had plenty of time to sit and talk until dinner was ready. Overall it turned out good with the Saucy chicken, egg noodles, baked potatoes, salad, bread, and yummy dessert. I was stuffed to the rafters! After dinner we all hung out and talked. It was a lot of fun. It reminded me how lucky I am to have such good friends! Oh, I almost forgot; I looked hot in my chef's apron :P
On Monday, my dad and I visited the Masonic Memorial to George Washington and Christ's Church in Old Town Alexandria. We made a quick visit to Five Guys before I took him to the airport. It was a quick trip, but I was so glad he came.
Kid Sister
Okay, so I realize this is my third entry of the day, but I've been crazy busy the past couple of weeks and feel that if I don't post now, it just won't get done. So there, hopefully its worth reading.
I got a phone call today from my little sister. She's about 7 years younger than me and one of my favorite people on the planet. She called me up and I answered the phone with some trepidation. She generally has not called me in the past unless she has needed something or something has happened in the family.
However, to my surprise and delight, she was calling to see how I was doing. It seems that she was talking to her friend Tucker this week. He had mentioned how close he was to his siblings and she had thought about how close she felt to each of her siblings. She wanted to be closer to all of us and decided that she was going to try to be a better sister. As part of this, she decided to call Chad and I today.
I was touched by her gesture and just felt distinctly how she was growing up. She's no longer a little girl, but has become a thoughtful and sensitive young woman who has her head squarely on her shoulders. I've seen her make some difficult decisions in the past year or two. She has reasserted herself and demonstrated her faith by the decisions she has made. She has worked hard and succeeded at school both in her coursework and in her extracurricular pursuits. She has also labored diligently to earn money to pay for college.
As great as those things are, it was wonderful to see her thinking about things with more of an external focus. She mentioned our little brother Ryan and how she has worked to stop fighting with him. I think he needs that. He's the second youngest and as a result has had to put up with a significant amount of grief from his older siblings. I am sure that he will appreciate her support and friendship.
Living out here on the east coast by myself has had its ups and downs. I love living here. I have wonderful friends and coworkers. I am blessed to be a member of a great ward of young single adults who do wonderful things and are just plain fun to be around. The one deficit that occasionally gets me down is how far away my family is. The bulk of my family is out west. I do have some relatives in Michigan, but it's not like I can just hop in the car and go visit for the weekend. I miss being around my little brothers and sisters (I'm not discriminating against older siblings as I'm the oldest :), my parents, and my grandparents. At some point I hope to have the means to travel out west to visit them more often than once per year.
I am grateful for my family. I miss them and love them a lot. I know that their prayers for me have been heard and answered repeatedly. I think of them often and pray for them as they are working through their trials and temptations. I am grateful for the power of the priesthood and that my family has been sealed in the temple. Families really are meant to be forever and I know I want mine to be.
I got a phone call today from my little sister. She's about 7 years younger than me and one of my favorite people on the planet. She called me up and I answered the phone with some trepidation. She generally has not called me in the past unless she has needed something or something has happened in the family.
However, to my surprise and delight, she was calling to see how I was doing. It seems that she was talking to her friend Tucker this week. He had mentioned how close he was to his siblings and she had thought about how close she felt to each of her siblings. She wanted to be closer to all of us and decided that she was going to try to be a better sister. As part of this, she decided to call Chad and I today.
I was touched by her gesture and just felt distinctly how she was growing up. She's no longer a little girl, but has become a thoughtful and sensitive young woman who has her head squarely on her shoulders. I've seen her make some difficult decisions in the past year or two. She has reasserted herself and demonstrated her faith by the decisions she has made. She has worked hard and succeeded at school both in her coursework and in her extracurricular pursuits. She has also labored diligently to earn money to pay for college.
As great as those things are, it was wonderful to see her thinking about things with more of an external focus. She mentioned our little brother Ryan and how she has worked to stop fighting with him. I think he needs that. He's the second youngest and as a result has had to put up with a significant amount of grief from his older siblings. I am sure that he will appreciate her support and friendship.
Living out here on the east coast by myself has had its ups and downs. I love living here. I have wonderful friends and coworkers. I am blessed to be a member of a great ward of young single adults who do wonderful things and are just plain fun to be around. The one deficit that occasionally gets me down is how far away my family is. The bulk of my family is out west. I do have some relatives in Michigan, but it's not like I can just hop in the car and go visit for the weekend. I miss being around my little brothers and sisters (I'm not discriminating against older siblings as I'm the oldest :), my parents, and my grandparents. At some point I hope to have the means to travel out west to visit them more often than once per year.
I am grateful for my family. I miss them and love them a lot. I know that their prayers for me have been heard and answered repeatedly. I think of them often and pray for them as they are working through their trials and temptations. I am grateful for the power of the priesthood and that my family has been sealed in the temple. Families really are meant to be forever and I know I want mine to be.
Confessions of a Law School Greenie: We're not in Provo anymore Toto
Okay, so one of the most important changes in my life is that as of Friday August 15th, I am part of the Fall 2008 entering class of law students. This past Friday I attended orientation at the George Mason University School of Law. I was there with about 250 other excited people. We had an introduction to our legal research and writing class that endeavored to teach us how to brief cases. Afterwords, we had a bbq in the school's atrium.
I was impressed at how nice everyone was. People were outgoing and friendly. I sat at a table with a bunch of other students in my section. It was fun meeting people and learning where they were from.
The next morning, we listened to the Dean give a speech in the atrium as we ate breakfast. Afterwards, we spent four hours in various breakout sessions covering the following topics: intro to law & econ class, how to use the library and other related services, student life, and career services. At one point in the middle of the day I definitely had some anxiety. I was getting a little nervous about everything that needed to be done before school begins on Thursday.
Throughout the course of the day, they did a wonderful job of keeping us full. Breakfast and lunch were good and there was pizza afterwards.
This may seem strange, but the two things I noticed the most about the experience had more to do with the social aspect than anything else. First, there was alcohol at every meal except breakfast. There was wine, pitchers of beer, as well as bottles of it. Honestly, I was so surprised. I hadn't thought about how the social scene would be so different from Provo. It's probably been almost 7 years since I've seen alcohol in such quantities. I was disappointed at the selection of soft drinks and ended up alternating between Sprite and water. The second thing I noticed was the way people dressed. It was like I'd been thrown back into high school. I saw girls in short shorts, tank tops that showed too much, and backless attire. I saw guys lowriding with their boxers hanging out of their shorts. It was a stark contrast to my four years at BYU.
Notwithstanding the differences in dressing and drinking preferences, I had a good time meeting people and am excited to get to know more of them. In particular, there were several people who went out of their way to help me. One guy, Rich B, helped me obtain a copy of my class schedule so that I could get my ID and take care of other administrative stuff. He went so far as to show me where the computer labs were and even paid for my print job (I could not without my ID card). He didn't have to do anything, but saw that he could help and jumped in. That's the second time that's happened at the school already. I really appreciated the help.
I was impressed at how nice everyone was. People were outgoing and friendly. I sat at a table with a bunch of other students in my section. It was fun meeting people and learning where they were from.
The next morning, we listened to the Dean give a speech in the atrium as we ate breakfast. Afterwards, we spent four hours in various breakout sessions covering the following topics: intro to law & econ class, how to use the library and other related services, student life, and career services. At one point in the middle of the day I definitely had some anxiety. I was getting a little nervous about everything that needed to be done before school begins on Thursday.
Throughout the course of the day, they did a wonderful job of keeping us full. Breakfast and lunch were good and there was pizza afterwards.
This may seem strange, but the two things I noticed the most about the experience had more to do with the social aspect than anything else. First, there was alcohol at every meal except breakfast. There was wine, pitchers of beer, as well as bottles of it. Honestly, I was so surprised. I hadn't thought about how the social scene would be so different from Provo. It's probably been almost 7 years since I've seen alcohol in such quantities. I was disappointed at the selection of soft drinks and ended up alternating between Sprite and water. The second thing I noticed was the way people dressed. It was like I'd been thrown back into high school. I saw girls in short shorts, tank tops that showed too much, and backless attire. I saw guys lowriding with their boxers hanging out of their shorts. It was a stark contrast to my four years at BYU.
Notwithstanding the differences in dressing and drinking preferences, I had a good time meeting people and am excited to get to know more of them. In particular, there were several people who went out of their way to help me. One guy, Rich B, helped me obtain a copy of my class schedule so that I could get my ID and take care of other administrative stuff. He went so far as to show me where the computer labs were and even paid for my print job (I could not without my ID card). He didn't have to do anything, but saw that he could help and jumped in. That's the second time that's happened at the school already. I really appreciated the help.
Russia's Infuriating Conduct
NY Times: International / Europe
Rice, in Georgia, Calls on Russia to Pull Out Now
By ANDREW E. KRAMER and CLIFFORD J. LEVY
Published: August 16, 2008
As the secretary of state tried to fix a loophole that Russia could use to justify its advance, Russian armor moved within 25 miles of Georgia’s capital, Tbilisi.
Russia's recent behavior infuriates me. I had a conversation via email with a friend earlier this week. Here are some of my views on the conflict, not to mention China's treatment of journalists during the Olympics.
Friend: Hey dude, you know this whole thing with Russia vs. Georgia. Bush declared our whole-hearted support for Georgia. Do you think that could be interpreted as a declaration of war? Another cold war would be less than tasteful, in my opinion.
Me: It's not a declaration of war. Right now it's all moral support. When the missiles and troops start moving and Congress gets involved, that is when it becomes a war. I don't see that happening, but honestly, I would like to shove Russia back into their own country. What they are doing is wrong. They lied and said they were there to keep the peace between the Georgian forces and the separatist forces. Instead, they are there to obliterate Georgia, if possible, get Georgia's oil fields and access to the Black Sea, and to just plain tick the US off and show our government that Russia is, in the minds of its leaders and citizens, strong again.
Friend: Wow. You know being the most benevolent bully on the playground has its pros and cons. I would hate to see that happen to Georgia, and I think we should stand with them if it comes to that, but I would hate to see us get embroiled in a conflict like that. Especially with the Olympics going on. I mean, c’mon!
Me: I really think we should back Georgia. Can you imagine the US invading Mexico to support two rebellious states there? The idea is just ludicrous.
As for the Olympics, I love the Games, but am angry at China's behavior. China and Russia are from the same cloth. They don't do things based on values and principles. They do them based on power, self-interest, and money. I know the US is often accused of the same thing, but when's the last time you saw Russia or China actually help another country? The US is a bully some of the time, but honestly, the buck gets passed to us every time. The Europeans are weak. They don't stand up and defend anything. I must exclude the UK from those statements. Of all the European countries, they are the most willing to put their money and troops forward to stand up for right. I think a big problem with Europe especially vis-a-vis Russia is that they depend on the oil and gas coming from Russia's fields and so are hard pressed to make a firm response knowing that Russia has the leverage. All the more reason to fast track alternative fuel research and applications.
Back to China - have you seen how they've cracked down on journalists during the Olympics?! People breathe the word "Tibet" and they end up beaten and imprisoned, despite China's promises that the press would not be molested during the Games. The native Chinese journalists have it the worst as there is no other government to protect them and the one that should be only cares about maintaining its power and control.
Rice, in Georgia, Calls on Russia to Pull Out Now
By ANDREW E. KRAMER and CLIFFORD J. LEVY
Published: August 16, 2008
As the secretary of state tried to fix a loophole that Russia could use to justify its advance, Russian armor moved within 25 miles of Georgia’s capital, Tbilisi.
Russia's recent behavior infuriates me. I had a conversation via email with a friend earlier this week. Here are some of my views on the conflict, not to mention China's treatment of journalists during the Olympics.
Friend: Hey dude, you know this whole thing with Russia vs. Georgia. Bush declared our whole-hearted support for Georgia. Do you think that could be interpreted as a declaration of war? Another cold war would be less than tasteful, in my opinion.
Me: It's not a declaration of war. Right now it's all moral support. When the missiles and troops start moving and Congress gets involved, that is when it becomes a war. I don't see that happening, but honestly, I would like to shove Russia back into their own country. What they are doing is wrong. They lied and said they were there to keep the peace between the Georgian forces and the separatist forces. Instead, they are there to obliterate Georgia, if possible, get Georgia's oil fields and access to the Black Sea, and to just plain tick the US off and show our government that Russia is, in the minds of its leaders and citizens, strong again.
Friend: Wow. You know being the most benevolent bully on the playground has its pros and cons. I would hate to see that happen to Georgia, and I think we should stand with them if it comes to that, but I would hate to see us get embroiled in a conflict like that. Especially with the Olympics going on. I mean, c’mon!
Me: I really think we should back Georgia. Can you imagine the US invading Mexico to support two rebellious states there? The idea is just ludicrous.
As for the Olympics, I love the Games, but am angry at China's behavior. China and Russia are from the same cloth. They don't do things based on values and principles. They do them based on power, self-interest, and money. I know the US is often accused of the same thing, but when's the last time you saw Russia or China actually help another country? The US is a bully some of the time, but honestly, the buck gets passed to us every time. The Europeans are weak. They don't stand up and defend anything. I must exclude the UK from those statements. Of all the European countries, they are the most willing to put their money and troops forward to stand up for right. I think a big problem with Europe especially vis-a-vis Russia is that they depend on the oil and gas coming from Russia's fields and so are hard pressed to make a firm response knowing that Russia has the leverage. All the more reason to fast track alternative fuel research and applications.
Back to China - have you seen how they've cracked down on journalists during the Olympics?! People breathe the word "Tibet" and they end up beaten and imprisoned, despite China's promises that the press would not be molested during the Games. The native Chinese journalists have it the worst as there is no other government to protect them and the one that should be only cares about maintaining its power and control.
Labels:
China,
freedom of the press,
Georgia,
human rights,
Russia
Monday, August 4, 2008
Solzhenitsyn - Солженицын
NY Times
Books
Books
By MICHAEL T. KAUFMAN
Published: August 4, 2008
I don't know what to say about him, other than that I respect him. I have read some of his work and hope to read more of it. Despite his cantankerous nature, he persisted in defiance to a system that did its best to destroy his life and the lives of millions of others. He knew the worth of his message and refused to be silenced.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

